What viewers observed about Carrie Underwood as the new “American Idol” judge in Episode 1

During the premiere, Underwood demonstrated her supportive nature when contestant Joey Cicconne experienced severe nervousness during his audition. Performing Harry Styles’ “Falling,” Cicconne had to pause mid-performance due to anxiety. Underwood, alongside fellow judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, encouraged him to sit and take deep breaths, sharing her own experiences to help ease his anxiety. This empathetic approach highlighted her understanding of the contestants’ pressures, reflecting her own journey on the show.

Underwood’s emotional engagement was evident when contestant Breanna Nix performed “Jesus, Take The Wheel,” a song popularized by Underwood herself. The performance moved Underwood to tears, especially as Nix’s young son sat on her lap during the audition. This moment resonated with viewers and showcased Underwood’s deep connection to the music and the contestants’ personal stories.

Fans on social media compared Underwood’s judging style to that of former judge Katy Perry, with many expressing a preference for Underwood’s approach. Viewers described her as “way better” and felt she “runs circles around” her predecessor, appreciating her authenticity and relatability.